Will Charitable Giving Die with the Death Tax?

October 23, 2017
Alec Borenstein

There are three crucial domestic subjects on our minds right now. First, Hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria. Our thoughts and prayers go out to Texas, Louisiana, Florida and Puerto Rico, especially in light of what we (in the New York City area) went through with Superstorm Sandy. It’s hard not to think about the devastation. If you’d like to give to the Red Cross, please CLICK HERE.

The second subject is fantasy football. But that’s not really my area of expertise as I have a hard time even making the playoffs in my fantasy football league. Also, many of my readers don’t care about fantasy football.

The third subject is tax reform. Trump has given numerous speeches about tax reform, and all of the political pundits say that Trump and the GOP need “a win” which must come from reforming our tax code.

An essential piece of tax reform is the repeal of the estate (or “death”) tax. Most conservatives want to repeal the estate tax and its tax rate of 40%. What many of these people do not know is that currently the federal estate tax exemption is $5,490,000 for a single person and almost $11,000,000 for a married couple. Only .02% of the estates in the country are subject to federal estate tax.

I read a fascinating Bloomberg articleabout the impact of the death of the death tax on charitable giving. In 2010, the last time we had no death tax in the country, gross charitable bequests totaled almost $7.5 billion, which was a 37% drop from $11.9 billion in 2009. When the death tax was resurrected in 2011, charitable giving soared to $14.36 billion.

Many conservatives are ambivalent as they contemplate the repeal of the death tax. On the one hand, GOPers are big believers in charitable giving. On the other hand, conservatives think the death tax is unAmerican and, according to Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio, “It’s peoples’ money. It’s their families’ money. It’s not the government’s money.”

The problem, as I see it, is that too many of our legislators are simply denying the truth. Death tax repeal does not hurt small businesses and farmers as many conservatives say. At most, it hurts 3% of farmers and small businesses.

Moreover, repeal of the estate tax will absolutely hurt charitable giving. There’s no way around it. According to the article (which I encourage you to read) our representatives think that repealing the estate tax will actually encourage “Americans to give more.” All of the evidence points to the contrary.

Thus, the debate. Repeal the unAmerican death tax or maintain the status quo and focus on other tax issues (like the corporate tax). Perhaps there is a middle ground, and I hope there is. Until then, the debate rages on.

(As an important aside to many of my readers, estate tax repeal also has a negative impact on the insurance industry. Wealthy households often use insurance products as: (1) estate tax paying vehicles, (2) charitable giving devices, or (3) estate equalization strategies. If there is no estate tax, there could be no reason for many wealthy people to buy these insurance products.)

To discuss your estate planning matter with us, contact Alec Borenstein, Esq., a partner with the firm at alec@bmcestateplanning.com or call 908-236-6457 today.


No items found.

Getting in touch

* indicates required

Want to know more about creating an estate plan or the probate process?

You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at alec@bmcestateplanning.com. We will treat your information with respect. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.

About us

Borenstein, McConnell & Calpin, P.C. is a Wills & Estate Planning law firm serving Central and Northern New Jersey, as well as New York City. We strive not only to give you a great client experience, but to become your trusted adviser for life. To reach Alec, please send an email to alec@bmcestateplanning.com.

NJ Offices:
155 Morris Avenue, Suite 201
Springfield, NJ 07081

3 Werner Way, Suite 230
Lebanon, NJ 08833

NY Office:
4607 Fort Hamilton Parkway
Brooklyn, NY 11219